Hollow Sections: Seamless, Porthole, and What the Weld Does to the Surface

A hollow section needs a hole, and there are only two ways to put one through an extruded aluminium profile: run the metal around a mandrel that is fixed to the stem, or split the billet into streams inside the die and weld them back together before they leave. The first is seamless and limited; the second is the porthole and bridge family and it produces almost every 6063 hollow sold. The choice is not only metallurgical — it decides the press load, the billet temperature, the container temperature, and whether a light line appears along the length of the finished, anodized profile.

The two routes

RouteHow the hole is madeWhere it is used
SeamlessA mandrel on the extrusion stem, either fixed to the stem or moving independently of the ram, pierces the billet and forms the boreRound tube and very simple hollow shapes; not practical for thin-walled products
Welding chamberThe billet is split into port streams around bridges, and the streams rejoin in a chamber around the mandrel before the exitTubes and hollow sections in alloys that rewelded; long lengths, very thin walls, complicated sections

The two ways to form a bore, and what each is good for. The welding-chamber route is the one with the wider industrial range, and it is why a 6063 hollow can be thin, long and complex.

What happens inside a porthole or bridge die

A solid billet enters, and the die splits it. The metal is forced into separate ports that run around the bridges supporting the mandrel, and the streams are brought together in a welding chamber that surrounds that mandrel. The section then leaves through the gap between the mandrel and the die cap, which is what sets the wall thickness. Because the streams are joined inside the die, where there is no atmospheric contamination, the published description is that a perfectly sound weld is obtained.

Two consequences follow from that geometry, and both are die-design decisions rather than press settings. The weld position is fixed by where the ports meet, and the weld quality is fixed by the chamber volume, the port area feeding each leg of the section, and how evenly the streams arrive. A porthole die that is starved on one side produces a weak weld on that side, which is the same imbalance that shows up as uneven wall thickness.

Three process differences from a solid die

Hollow-section extrusion is not a solid profile with a hole in it. Three published differences change the settings:

  • Load goes up. The metal has to overcome friction drag while flowing through the ports before it reaches the welding chamber, so the extrusion load is higher than for a solid section of the same exit area.
  • The billet usually has to be above 500 °C. That temperature is what allows flow through the ports and a proper weld in the chamber.
  • The container has to run high. It should be relatively high and not less than 50 to 70 °C below the billet temperature — 450 to 470 °C — for satisfactory extrusion and welding on thick-walled sections.

The third item is the one that causes the most argument on a shop floor, because it is close to the reverse of the rule for hard alloys, where a large billet-to-container difference is used deliberately to arrest oxide on the liner. On a hollow 6xxx profile the container is kept near the billet, because the weld needs the metal hot and fluid in the chamber. The oxide-control rule and the weld rule pull in different directions, and the die type decides which one applies.

Where the weld should be, once it is anodized

A longitudinal weld can appear lighter than the rest of the section after anodizing. This is a metallurgical effect, not dirt and not a polishing fault, and no amount of finishing removes it. What the die designer controls is where it lands: the published recommendation is to place the welds at the corners of the hollow section, where the eye and the light do not find them.

That is a specification question more than a die-shop preference. If the customer anodizes, the die drawing should show where the ports meet and the welds land, and the answer should be “at the corners” before the die is cut rather than after the first anodized sample.

Which alloys reweld properly

The welding-chamber route depends on the alloy being willing to weld to itself under pressure in the chamber. The published ratings for the soft and medium-strength alloys are below.

AlloyWelding properties
Pure aluminumVery good
AlMnVery good
AlMg1Very good
AlMgSi0.5Good to very good
AlMgSi0.8Good to very good
AlMgSi1Good to very good
AlZnMg1Good

Welding properties of the soft and medium-strength alloys for tubes and hollow sections. The 6xxx grades that most hollow profiles are specified in are not the best welders on this list — they are good to very good, which is why the chamber and the weld position matter.

When the weld is not good enough

An improperly bonded weld joint does not announce itself on the outside of the profile. It shows at the fracture: a section that splits along the line where the two streams met, a cross-section with two poor-quality welds visible inside the wall, or a joint that is only partially bonded. On a hollow extrusion for structural use that is a reject; on round stock destined for drawing it is worse, because the joint has to survive the drawing passes as well.

The inspection that catches it is destructive and cheap: cut a section, etch it, and look at the weld line. Doing that on the first billet of a run costs a piece of scrap and answers the question the outside of the profile cannot answer.

Small hollows and multihole dies

Small hollow shapes are produced on multihole porthole dies, and the number of holes is not arbitrary. The published selection criteria are the extrusion ratio of each hole, the extrudability of the alloy, the press size, and the circumscribing circle of the section. Each hole gets its own ratio, so adding holes to speed the press up also reduces the ratio per hole and changes the metal flow inside every one of them.

That is the same trade as the acceleration lever on the solid side, with an extra constraint: more holes means more welds per billet and more chances for one of them to be poor. The hole count is a quality decision as much as a productivity decision.

Where this leaves a die steel order

A hollow die stresses the steel differently from a solid one. The mandrel and the bridges are thin sections carrying the full extrusion load at temperature, the chamber walls see the metal twice, and the die cap gap sets the wall thickness with almost no room for deflection. The grade is still chromium hot work steel — AISI H13 and its European equivalent 1.2344 — and the working hardness and temper are on the H13 tool steel page, with the extrusion programme on the 1.2344 ESR H13 page.

The stack and the hollow-die options are described on the die types and tooling page, the surface defects a hollow profile collects on the pick-up and die lines page, the bearing that sets exit temperature on the die bearing length page, and the wall-thickness limits for a given circumscribing circle on the circumscribing circle diameter page.

Before you quote a hollow die from this page

These are the published mechanisms, alloy ratings and process differences, not a die design. Weld quality is set by the port layout, the chamber and the metal balance of a specific section, and a die that welds acceptably in one press may not in another. Confirm the weld position against the customer’s finishing specification, and etch the first billet before the run continues.

Source, Aluminum Extrusion Technology, P. K. Saha, ASM International, 2000, chapter 6, extrusion of tubes and hollow shapes, pages 167 to 170, with the weld-joint figures on pages 181 to 182.